{"id":33613,"date":"2025-12-03T12:00:00","date_gmt":"2025-12-03T12:00:00","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/"},"modified":"2026-07-02T17:46:02","modified_gmt":"2026-07-02T17:46:02","slug":"ir-notes-263-03-december-2025","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/","title":{"rendered":"IR Notes 263 &#8211; Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC"},"content":{"rendered":"<div class=\"irnotes-imported-table-wrapper\">\n<table width=\"660\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" align=\"center\" class=\"irnotes-table-1\">\n    <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-1\">\n        <td width=\"221\" valign=\"top\" bgcolor=\"#e9e9e9\" class=\"irnotes-td-1\">\n            <table width=\"221\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-2\">\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-2\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-2\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif\" width=\"221\" height=\"166\" class=\"irnotes-img-1\" \/><\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-3\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-3\">\n                        <table width=\"221\" height=\"30\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-3\">\n                            <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-4\">\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-4\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                                <td class=\"irnotes-td-5\">\n                                    <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-2\" class=\"irnotes-font-1\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-1\">IR Notes 263 &#8211; 03 December 2025<\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#0075c5\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-2\" class=\"irnotes-font-2\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-2\">www.irshare.eu<\/b>\n                                    <\/font>\n                                <\/td>\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-6\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                            <\/tr>\n                        <\/table>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-5\">\n                    <td height=\"10\" class=\"irnotes-td-7\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-6\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-8\">\n                        <table width=\"221\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-4\">\n                            <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-7\">\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-9\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                                <td class=\"irnotes-td-10\">\n                                    <font color=\"#000000\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-3\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-3\">A question for\u2026<\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"2\" class=\"irnotes-font-4\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-4\">Pascale Rauline, Secretary of AXA\u2019s Group European Works Council (CEG)\n                                        <\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/><br \/>\n                                    <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764762909_Pascale_Rauline.jpg\"\n                                        style=\"max-width:80px; padding-right:5px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-2\" \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#747575\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\" class=\"irnotes-font-5\">\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-1\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-1\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-1\">AXA Group\u2019s management and its\n                                                    European Works Council have signed a charter on social dialogue\n                                                    around artificial intelligence (see Companies). Is this the\n                                                    outcome of a process conducted by employee\n                                                    representatives?<br \/><\/strong><\/span><span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-2\">Well, the AXA CEG has been working on AI for\n                                                about fifteen years now, in fact ever since data exploitation and\n                                                digitalisation became widespread. From 2023 onwards, we at the CEG\n                                                began to work more specifically on generative AI, firstly by\n                                                including this topic on the agenda of our annual plenary sessions,\n                                                and then, from 2025 onwards, by devoting two of the CEG Bureau\u2019s\n                                                monthly meetings to this topic. The aim is to conduct regular\n                                                reviews with management covering its strategy in this area, progress\n                                                in the use of these technologies, and employee training. Our main\n                                                role is to ensure that all employees are included in the changes\n                                                linked to this trend, and that nobody is left behind, paying\n                                                particular attention to the issue of maintaining employability. This\n                                                year, we wanted to formalise this step in a charter signed with the\n                                                Group\u2019s management, setting out the basic principles of a\n                                                responsible AI transformation: transparency, ethical issues,\n                                                fairness, human supervision, data protection and environmental\n                                                considerations. By signing this text, management is committing\n                                                itself to nurture social dialogue on AI, both at European level and\n                                                within each employee representation body at national level. We want\n                                                to boost an ongoing social dialogue on AI everywhere, in the spirit\n                                                of the 2020 European framework agreement on digitalisation. Lastly,\n                                                the charter emphasises the importance of training. Once again, I\n                                                stress that the aim is to ensure that <span\n                                                    style=\"text-decoration-line: underline;\" class=\"irnotes-span-3\">all<\/span> employees\n                                                are included, so that responsible adoption of AI systems will become\n                                                something as natural as using the Internet and email.<\/span><\/p>\n                                    <\/font>\n                                <\/td>\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-11\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                            <\/tr>\n                        <\/table>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-8\">\n                    <td height=\"20\" class=\"irnotes-td-12\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/sep.gif\" width=\"221\" height=\"2\" class=\"irnotes-img-3\" \/>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-9\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-13\">\n                        <table width=\"221\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-5\">\n                            <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-10\">\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-14\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                                <td class=\"irnotes-td-15\">\n                                    <font color=\"#800000\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-6\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-5\">Agenda<\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#747575\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\" class=\"irnotes-font-7\">\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-2\">\u00a0<\/p><br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-3\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-4\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-2\">4\n                                                    December<\/strong><\/span><br \/><span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-5\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-3\">Lisbon (and\n                                                    online)<\/strong><\/span><br \/><span class=\"irnotes-span-6\">A conference organise<\/span>d\n                                            by the European Trade Union Institute, Pr\u00e1xis and the Centro de\n                                            Investiga\u00e7\u00e3o e Estudos de Sociologia (CIES-Iscte), entitled \u201c<a\n                                                href=\"https:\/\/www.etui.org\/sites\/default\/files\/2025-10\/Draft%20agenda_ETUI%20BLER%20book%20event%20LIsboa_EN_20.10.2025_clean.pdf\" class=\"irnotes-a-1\">Reviving\n                                                worker participation in Portugal and Europe: towards a progressive\n                                                agenda to democratise the economy<\/a>\u201d.<\/p><br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-4\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-7\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-4\">4\n                                                    December<\/strong><\/span><br \/><span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-8\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-5\">Noisy-Le-Grand and\n                                                    online<\/strong><\/span><br \/>IRES international seminar\n                                            discussing the research paper on\u00a0<a\n                                                href=\"https:\/\/ires.fr\/evenements\/seminaire-international-de-lires\/decathlon-ou-les-tactiques-de-la-vertu-sociologie-politique-dune-entreprise-citoyenne-4-decembre-2025\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-2\"><em>D\u00e9cathlon\n                                                    ou les tactiques de la vertu d\u2019une entreprise citoyenne<\/em><\/a>\n                                            [\u201c<span class=\"irnotes-span-9\">D\u00e9cathlon or the virtue-signalling tactics employed by a good\n                                                corporate citizen\u201d<\/span>]. Registration compulsory via\u00a0<a\n                                                href=\"mailto:contact@ires.fr\" class=\"irnotes-a-3\">contact@ires.fr<\/a><\/p>\n                                    <\/font>\n                                <\/td>\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-16\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                            <\/tr>\n                        <\/table>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-11\">\n                    <td height=\"20\" class=\"irnotes-td-17\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/sep.gif\" width=\"221\" height=\"2\" class=\"irnotes-img-4\" \/>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-12\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-18\">\n                        <table width=\"221\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-6\">\n                            <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-13\">\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-19\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                                <td class=\"irnotes-td-20\">\n                                    <font color=\"#800000\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-8\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-6\">Who we are?<\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#747575\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\" class=\"irnotes-font-9\">\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-5\">\u00a0<\/p><br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-6\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-10\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-6\">IR Notes <\/strong><\/span>is\u00a0a\n                                            fortnightly newsletter produced by<span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-11\">\n                                                <strong class=\"irnotes-strong-7\">IR Share <\/strong><\/span>and its network of experts, and is\n                                            available in several European languages (English, French, German,\n                                            Italian, Spanish, Polish). It offers Europe-wide monitoring of\n                                            employment law, labour relations and employment policy. It is available\n                                            by subscription for 273 euros per year .<\/p><br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-7\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-12\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-8\">The team: <\/strong><\/span>This\n                                            issue was producaed by\u00a0<span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-13\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-9\">In\u00e8s\n                                                    Bollet<\/strong><\/span>,<span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-14\">\n                                                <strong class=\"irnotes-strong-10\">Victoria Fonseca<\/strong><\/span>,\u00a0<span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-15\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-11\">Ambre\n                                                    Grenier-Boley<\/strong><\/span>,\u00a0<span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-16\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-12\">Laura\u00a0Renucci<\/strong><\/span>,<strong class=\"irnotes-strong-13\"><span\n                                                    style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-17\"> Iris Turlan<\/span><\/strong> and\u00a0<span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-18\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-14\">Fr\u00e9d\u00e9ric Turlan<\/strong><\/span>.\n                                            Find out more about the\u00a0<a href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/about\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-4\">IR Share\n                                                team<\/a> on our website.<\/p><br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-8\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-19\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-15\">Subscribe to IR Notes\n                                                <\/strong><\/span>Via the\u00a0<a\n                                                href=\"http:\/\/www.irshare.eu\/en\/subscribe-to-ir-notes-_54.html\" class=\"irnotes-a-5\">IR\n                                                Share website<\/a> or by calling us on: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95\n                                            or<br \/>E-mail:\u00a0<a\n                                                href=\"mailto:frederic.t@irshare.eu\" class=\"irnotes-a-6\">frederic.t@irshare.eu<\/a><\/p>\n                                        <br \/>\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-9\"><span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-20\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-16\">Legal notice.<\/strong>\n                                            <\/span>Publisher: IR Share SARL &#8211; 5, Les Comp\u00e8res &#8211; 89520 Fontenoy,\n                                            France \u2013 Tel.: +33 (0)6 81 41 53 95 \u2013 share capital 1,500 euros \u2013\n                                            commercial register (RCS Auxerre): 512 567\u00a0959. Managing editor:\n                                            Fr\u00e9d\u00e9ric Turlan. Hosting: ALTEO by Damien Cornillet &#8211; Ch\u00e2teau &#8211; 89500\n                                            Villeneuve-sur-Yonne. CPPAP\u00a0no.: 0626 Z 93933<strong class=\"irnotes-strong-17\">.<\/strong><\/p>\n                                    <\/font>\n                                <\/td>\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-21\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                            <\/tr>\n                        <\/table>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-14\">\n                    <td height=\"20\" class=\"irnotes-td-22\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/sep.gif\" width=\"221\" height=\"2\" class=\"irnotes-img-5\" \/>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-15\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-23\">\n                        <table width=\"221\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-7\">\n                            <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-16\">\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-24\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                                <td class=\"irnotes-td-25\">\n                                    <font color=\"#800000\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-10\">\n                                        <b class=\"irnotes-b-7\">Follow us on LinkedIn!<\/b>\n                                    <\/font><br \/> <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764687362_Linkedin.png\"\n                                        style=\"max-width:80px; padding-right:5px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-6\" \/>\n                                    <font color=\"#747575\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\" class=\"irnotes-font-11\">\n                                        <p class=\"irnotes-p-10\"><span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-21\">Why not connect to the <\/span><a\n                                                href=\"https:\/\/www.linkedin.com\/company\/ir-notes\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-7\">IR Notes<\/a><span\n                                                style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-22\"> LinkedIn page, so that you can keep up with\n                                                developments in the issues we\u2019re covering, between two editions?\n                                                You\u2019re welcome to follow us! There are already 774 of you following\n                                                us!<\/span><\/p>\n                                    <\/font>\n                                <\/td>\n                                <td width=\"5\" class=\"irnotes-td-26\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n                            <\/tr>\n                        <\/table>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-17\">\n                    <td height=\"20\" class=\"irnotes-td-27\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/sep.gif\" width=\"221\" height=\"2\" class=\"irnotes-img-7\" \/>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-18\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-28\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/newsletter\/logo-signature.gif\" width=\"21\" height=\"21\"\n                            align=\"left\" style=\"padding:0 10px 0 10px\" class=\"irnotes-img-8\" \/>\n                        <div style=\"padding:0 10px 0 10px\">\n                            <font color=\"#747575\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\" class=\"irnotes-font-12\">\n                                <p class=\"irnotes-p-11\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-18\"><em><a href=\"http:\/\/www.irshare.eu\/en\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-8\">IR Share<\/a><\/em><\/strong><em> is\n                                        a privately- owned, independent, apolitical company whose aim is to inform\n                                        and assist all players involved in social dialogue within and outside\n                                        Europe. It has been the correspondent organisation for France of the\u00a0<a\n                                            href=\"https:\/\/www.eurofound.europa.eu\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-9\">European Foundation for the\n                                            Improvement of Living and Working Conditions<\/a> since 2009.<\/em><\/p>\n                            <\/font>\n                        <\/div>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n\n            <\/table>\n        <\/td>\n        <td width=\"10\" class=\"irnotes-td-29\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n        <td width=\"419\" valign=\"top\" bgcolor=\"#FFFFFF\" class=\"irnotes-td-30\">\n            <table width=\"419\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" class=\"irnotes-table-8\">\n\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-19\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-31\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"4\" class=\"irnotes-font-13\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-8\">Lead\n                                story<\/b><\/font> <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-14\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-9\">Towards an\n                                epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757007_shutterstock_2449839539.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-9\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-15\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-12\">As indicated in our last edition (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/irnotes_en_1425.html\" class=\"irnotes-a-10\">IR Notes\n                                    262<\/a>), Ireland\u2019s High Court has handed down an important <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/verizon-high-court-judgment-case-between-jean-philippe-charpentier-against-verizon-ireland\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-11\">judgment<\/a>\n                                in the case brought by Jean-Philippe Charpentier, Verizon EWC Secretary (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/irnotes_en_1341.html\" class=\"irnotes-a-12\">IR Notes 250<\/a>)\n                                against Verizon\u2019s management. The High Court overturned the decision pronounced on\n                                appeal by the Labour Court, which had found entirely in favour of the group\u2019s\n                                management.<br \/>In November 2021, a number of EWC members acting in a personal\n                                capacity, including its secretary, took their case to the Workplace Relations\n                                Commission (WRC), which is the competent body for resolving collective labour\n                                disputes in Ireland [editor\u2019s note: under Irish law, an EWC has no legal personality\n                                of its own, and therefore cannot take matters to court]. The complainants applied\n                                for the company\u2019s management to be ordered to pay the costs they had incurred by\n                                taking part in a training course for EWC members, and also to pay certain expert\n                                legal costs incurred by the EWC. The WRC ruled that the EWC had already benefitted\n                                from a training day organised by management, so the latter was not obliged to\n                                reimburse the costs incurred by the 4 members in attending a further seminar \u2013\n                                especially given that management had notified them in advance that they would not\n                                pay these costs. As for the expert costs, the WRC drew a distinction between areas\n                                of expertise that, in its view, qualified for reimbursement, and those that did not\n                                (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/verizon-workplace-relations-commission-24-april-2023-jean-philippe-charpentier-ewc-chairperson-v-verizon-ireland-limited-2\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-13\">decision<\/a>\n                                and <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/maj\/irnotes\/gen.php?id_irnotes=1077&amp;lg=en&amp;action=gen\" class=\"irnotes-a-14\">IR\n                                    Notes 207<\/a>) and concluded that management should pay 50% of the eligible\n                                costs.\u00a0However, on appeal, on 27 August 2024, the Labour Court handed down two\n                                decisions: one confirming that the training costs did not have to be reimbursed, and\n                                the other dismissing the workforce representatives\u2019 application for expert costs to\n                                be refunded (see <a href=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/irnotes_en_1257.html\" class=\"irnotes-a-15\">IR\n                                    Notes\n                                    236<\/a>). In fact the Labour Court overturned the WRC\u2019s decision, holding that\n                                the employees\u2019 representative was not entitled to act (<a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/ireland-labour-court-27-august-2024-verizon-vs-j-p-charpentier-decision-tid241\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-16\">decision\n                                    TID241<\/a>). As a last resort, the employee representatives then decided to\n                                refer the case to the High Court.<br \/>In its judgment, which is the first one in\n                                this field handed down in Ireland, the High Court notes that the Labour Court had\n                                made several \u201cerrors of law\u201d. With the exception of training costs, which the High\n                                Court confirms did not have to be paid by the employer, given that it had already\n                                presented an EWC training course that was deemed adequate, the High Court disputes\n                                all of the Labour Court\u2019s conclusions. The Labour Court made errors of law by\n                                excluding a collective complaint filed by the EWC; by rejecting the EWC secretary\u2019s\n                                capacity as an EWC representative; by not ruling on the matter of whether the expert\n                                costs were necessary and appropriate;\u00a0and by not taking account of the application\n                                to have the legal fees of the EWC secretary\u2019s barrister refunded, solely on the\n                                grounds that its appeal had been rejected. In particular, the High Court notes that\n                                \u201cthe EWC, having no separate legal personality or independent financial resources,\n                                could only proceed with expert, including legal, advice and assistance\u201d. To ensure\n                                that EWC members\u2019 rights could be properly exercised, \u201cthe Labour Court should have\n                                considered whether it could, or should, permit an EWC or an employee to seek\n                                agreement from central management to reimburse all or some of the legal expenses\n                                associated with the claim on the basis that those expenses were necessary to satisfy\n                                the requirement of s. 17(1A) [editor\u2019s note: of the law transposing the European\n                                Works Council directive into Irish law] that an EWC member or employee\n                                representative had the means required to apply the rights conferred by the\n                                Directive.\u201d<br \/>Looking beyond the Verizon case, this landmark case has made a\n                                significant contribution to the adoption of the revised European Works Council\n                                directive, which plans to abolish the legal restriction preventing an EWC from\n                                taking a matter to court, notably in Ireland, where any dispute must be instigated\n                                by individuals acting in a personal capacity, at their own expense \u2013 a situation\n                                that represents a practical obstacle to challenging any decisions made by management\n                                (see also\u00a0IR <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/maj\/irnotes\/gen.php?id_irnotes=1059&amp;lg=en&amp;action=gen\" class=\"irnotes-a-17\">Notes\n                                    204<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-20\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-32\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"4\" class=\"irnotes-font-16\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-10\">1. European\n                                Union<\/b><\/font> <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-17\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-11\">Project<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764681721_shutterstock_2159614043.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-10\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-18\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-13\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-23\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-19\">Artificial intelligence : <\/strong><\/span>On 19\n                                November, the European Commission put forward a new \u201cOmnibus\u201d package, which aims to\n                                simplify several pieces of digital legislation, including the regulation governing\n                                artificial intelligence or \u201cAI Act\u201d (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/commission.europa.eu\/news-and-media\/news\/simpler-digital-rules-help-eu-businesses-grow-2025-11-19_en\" class=\"irnotes-a-18\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). Its <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/ensure-timely-and-proportionate-implementation-of-certain-of-the-ai-acts-provisions\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-19\">proposal\n                                    for a regulation amending the AI Act<\/a> aims, among other things, to delay\n                                implementation of the rules relating to high-risk AI systems until the Commission\n                                has had time to prepare tools and guidelines to help suppliers to comply with the\n                                requirements. In employment terms, the systems concerned are those used for:\n                                recruitment or selection purposes; taking decisions concerning the terms of\n                                employment relationships, promotion or termination of employment relationships;\n                                assigning tasks on the basis of individual behaviour, personality traits or personal\n                                characteristics; or monitoring and evaluating workers\u2019 performance and behaviour.\n                                Suppliers will have until the end of December 2027 (rather than August 2026) to\n                                demonstrate that their systems are not prejudicial to candidates\u2019 and workers\u2019\n                                fundamental rights, and that they will continue to be systematically supervised by a\n                                human.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-21\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-33\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-19\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-12\">Social\n                                update<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764681954_shutterstock_1308197251.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-11\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-20\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-14\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-24\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-20\">European Semester : <\/strong><\/span>On 25\n                                November, the European Commission adopted the autumn package of the European\n                                Semester 2026, with a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/european-semester-autumn-package-sets-out-economic-and-employment-policy-priorities-to-boost-competitiveness\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-20\">communication<\/a>\n                                that defines economic and employment policy priorities (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/ec.europa.eu\/commission\/presscorner\/detail\/en\/ip_25_2760\" class=\"irnotes-a-21\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). In addition, and for the first time, the Commission has put\n                                forward a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/urgent-actions-to-tackle-human-capital-related-structural-challenges\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-22\">Council\n                                    recommendation on human capital<\/a>, calling on the Twenty-Seven to prioritise\n                                i) the education and skills needed in strategic sectors of the EU economy (clean\n                                transition, circular economy, industrial decarbonisation, defence and space\n                                industry, etc.) and ii) boosting programmes in the fields of science, technology,\n                                engineering and mathematics (STEM). States are also urged to \u201creverse the negative\n                                trend in basic skills\u201d. Furthermore, the <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/employment-and-social-situation-in-the-eu\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-23\">proposal\n                                    for a joint employment report<\/a> expresses concern regarding the \u201cslow growth\u201d\n                                of labour productivity and \u201csizeable skills and labour shortages\u201d. The <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/joint-employment-report\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-24\">Annex<\/a> of this report\n                                includes the first-stage analysis of the social convergence framework (SCF) based on\n                                the social scoreboard. The Commission points out that several parts of the autumn\n                                package highlight \u201cthe importance of social dialogue\u201d (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/employment-social-affairs.ec.europa.eu\/news\/autumn-package-emphasizing-role-social-partners-eu-policymaking-2025-11-27_en\" class=\"irnotes-a-25\">press\n                                    release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-22\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-34\">\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764682108_shutterstock_2451038735.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-12\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-21\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-15\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-25\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-21\">Restructuring : <\/strong><\/span>On 27 November,\n                                the European Commission launched a Skills Guarantee Pilot project with a budget of\n                                14.5 million euros, which will focus on workers from the automotive industry and its\n                                supply chain, who are at risk of unemployment (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/employment-social-affairs.ec.europa.eu\/news\/commission-launches-skills-guarantee-support-workers-transition-learning-new-skills-strategic-2025-11-27_en?prefLang=fr\" class=\"irnotes-a-26\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). To this end, it has published a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/socialinnovationplus.eu\/call\/esf-si-2025-skills-guarantee-01\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-27\">call\n                                    for proposals<\/a> (deadline: 29 January 2026) to fund schemes to speed up and\n                                improve the transition of these workers to jobs in companies in growing or emerging\n                                strategic sectors, by providing targeted upskilling and reskilling programmes.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-23\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-35\">\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764682699_Image1.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-13\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-22\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-16\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-26\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-22\">A \u201csocial\u201d Omnibus directive :\n                                    <\/strong><\/span>In the wake of seeing the European Commission put forward\n                                \u201cOmnibus\u201d directives in order to simplify whole swathes of EU legislation, the idea\n                                of a specific Omnibus directive for European social legislation is gaining ground\n                                among EU employers. The European Chemical Employers Group (ECEG) has published a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/eceg-proposals-for-burden-reduction-in-eu-social-affairs-social-omnibus\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-28\">table<\/a>\n                                of proposals for simplifications in this area. However, IndustriAll Europe is\n                                critical of this ECEG-led campaign, saying it is \u201caimed at rolling back\n                                worker-focused legislation, (&#8230;) is opportunistic, and it distracts from the\n                                existential issues the sector must urgently confront\u201d,\u00a0(see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/news.industriall-europe.eu\/Article\/1383\" class=\"irnotes-a-29\">press release<\/a>). This\n                                warning did not prevent four other sector-specific employers\u2019 organisations (Ceemet,\n                                EFB, Hotrec, WEC Europe) from launching a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/sectoral-employers-organisations-call-for-simplification-and-enforcement-of-the-social-acquis\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-30\">Call\n                                    for simplification and enforcement of the social acquis<\/a>, on 1 December.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-24\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-36\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-23\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-13\">Trade\n                                unionism<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764683061_shutterstock_2606024617.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-14\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-24\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-17\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-27\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-23\">Restructuring : <\/strong><\/span>On 12 November,\n                                the European Transport Workers\u2019 Federation published <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/support-unions-and-workers-representatives-during-transnational-company-restructurings\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-31\">new\n                                    guidelines<\/a> for supporting trade unions and employee representatives at the\n                                time of transnational company restructurings. EWCs and trade-union networks within\n                                transnational companies are presented as \u201ckey tools to detect early warning signs,\n                                share information, and coordinate union strategies at the European level\u201d (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.etf-europe.org\/etf-strengthens-cross-border-coordination-with-new-restructuring-guidelines\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-32\">press\n                                    release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-25\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-37\">\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764683362_Image2.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-15\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-25\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-18\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-28\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-24\">Future of industry : <\/strong><\/span>The\n                                IndustriAll Europe trade union federation has published a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/out-of-18-key-industrial-sectors-only-two-aerospace-and-defence-remains-in-globally-competitive-shape\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-33\">report<\/a>\n                                on the risks of deindustrialisation in the EU, prepared by the consultancy firm\n                                Syndex. According to the authors, of the 18 industrial sectors analysed, only\n                                aerospace and defence appear not to be at risk in the short term. The report says\n                                that \u201call the other sectors are struggling facing harsh US and Chinese competition\u201d.\n                                The document contains recommendations, aimed at decision-makers, for preventing\n                                Europe\u2019s deindustrialisation, and supports some trade union demands, such as\u00a0the\n                                creation of a mechanism, inspired by the SURE programme, \u201cto prevent irreversible\n                                industrial job losses\u201d (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/news.industriall-europe.eu\/Article\/1390\" class=\"irnotes-a-34\">press release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-26\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-38\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"4\" class=\"irnotes-font-26\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-14\">2. Member\n                                States<\/b><\/font> <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-27\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-15\">Germany<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757066_shutterstock_2419417811.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-16\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-28\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-19\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-29\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-25\">Deforestation regulation : <\/strong><\/span>The\n                                trade union IG Metall and the employers\u2019 organisation HDH have called on the Federal\n                                Chancellor and the EU to intervene and cut bureaucracy linked to the European\n                                regulation on deforestation (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.igmetall.de\/presse\/pressemitteilungen\/eu-entwaldungsverordnung-ig-metall-und-holzindustrie-wende\" class=\"irnotes-a-35\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). The signatories warn of the risks of lost production, job losses,\n                                and rising costs for consumers. Under the new regulation, timber must have a\n                                declaration of origin, but this requirement is currently giving rise to difficulties\n                                in implementation, reported by SME in particular.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-27\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-39\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-29\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-16\">Cyprus<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757103_shutterstock_2505324085.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-17\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-30\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-20\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-30\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-26\">Index-linking wages : <\/strong><\/span>On 13\n                                November, the government concluded an <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/gradual-full-restoration-of-the-rate-of-payment-of-the-indexation-allowance\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-36\">agreement<\/a>\n                                aimed at achieving a gradual full restoration of the automatic mechanism for\n                                adjusting wages to match inflation (Cost-of-Living Allowance \u2013 CoLA \/ Automatic\n                                Tariff Adjustment \u2013 ATA). This agreement, which is the outcome of protracted\n                                negotiations between organisations representing workers and employers, provides for\n                                the indexation allowance to be raised to 80% of the increase in the consumer price\n                                index (excluding consumption taxes) in January 2026, to 90% on 1 July 2026, and\n                                subsequently to 100% on 1 January 2027. The social partners say that they are\n                                satisfied with the final outcome, as set out in the newsletter of the OEB \u2014 the\n                                Cyprus Employers &amp; Industrialists Federation (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.oeb.org.cy\/en\/oeb-circular-permanent-agreement-on-the-cost-of-living-adjustment-cola\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-37\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). Index-linking will also apply once every two years to the national\n                                minimum wage.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-28\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-40\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-31\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-17\">Croatia<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764684607_Image3.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-18\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-32\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-21\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-31\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-27\">AI and employment : <\/strong><\/span>The\n                                Friedrich Ebert Foundation has performed a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.sssh.hr\/pdf\/whatwedo-researchs\/publikacija_uiiradnamjesta_final.pdf\" class=\"irnotes-a-38\">survey<\/a>\n                                of trade unionists\u2019 use and perception of artificial intelligence (AI), on behalf of\n                                the Union of Autonomous Trade Unions of Croatia (UATUC) (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.sssh.hr\/novost\/predstavljen-sazetak-istrazivanja-o-umjetnoj-inteligenciji-i-radnim-mjestima\" class=\"irnotes-a-39\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). The study shows that trade union members are aware of the issues\n                                involved with AI, but remain fairly unprepared when it comes to using it. 49.7% of\n                                participants make little use of AI, and those who use it, do so for administrative\n                                tasks. Consequently, there is a significant need for trade unions to receive\n                                education in this area, so that a strategic and proactive position can be reached.\n                            <\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-29\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-41\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-33\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-18\">Greece<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764762660_Roxana_M-nzatu.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-19\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-34\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-22\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-32\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-28\">Collective bargaining : <\/strong><\/span>On 26\n                                November, the Minister of Labour and Social Security, Niki Kerameus, signed an\n                                agreement with representatives of the country\u2019s main employers\u2019 and employees\u2019\n                                organisations. This historic agreement aims to strengthen collective labour\n                                agreements and to increase the numbers of workers covered by them. The action plan\n                                to implement this agreement, which is required under the EU directive on adequate\n                                minimum wages, will be published in December, and is due to be supplemented by\n                                legislation in early 2026. During a visit to Brussels on 1 December, the Greek\n                                minister saw this agreement welcomed by Roxana M\u00eenzatu, the European Commission\u2019s\n                                Executive Vice-President for Social Rights (see photo), who believes that it is a\n                                source of inspiration for other EU countries in terms of social dialogue.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-30\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-42\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-35\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-19\">Poland<\/b>\n                        <\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757187_shutterstock_2482763561.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-20\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-36\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-23\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-33\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-29\">A new tool for contracts :\n                                    <\/strong><\/span>Working in conjunction with social partners, the national labour\n                                inspectorate has compiled a checklist to help companies to become more effective in\n                                choosing the right type of employment contract when they recruit workers (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.pip.gov.pl\/aktualnosci\/drugi-dzien-konsultacji-z-partnerami-spolecznymi-w-sprawie-tzw-listy-kontrolnej\" class=\"irnotes-a-40\">press\n                                    release<\/a>). The parties involved also want to boost workers\u2019 knowledge of\n                                labour law, and thereby help prevent instances of abuse. However, the employers\u2019\n                                organisations have criticised these measures, fearing that they will impair the\n                                process of cost optimisation (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/fzz.org.pl\/spotkanie-mrpips-projektu-ustawy-pip-ud283\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-41\">press\n                                    release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-31\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-43\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"4\" class=\"irnotes-font-37\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-20\">3.\n                                Companies<\/b><\/font> <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-38\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-21\">European\n                                Works Councils<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764756930_Image1.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-21\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-39\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-24\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-34\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-30\">Artificial intelligence : <\/strong><\/span>On 27\n                                November, Thomas Buberl, CEO of <span\n                                    style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-35\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-31\">AXA<\/strong><\/span> and President of the AXA\n                                group\u2019s European Works Council (CEG), and Pascale Rauline, CEG secretary, jointly\n                                signed a <a href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/iterative-social-dialogue-on-ai\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-42\">charter on\n                                    the conduct of European social dialogue in the context of the development of\n                                    artificial intelligence within the group<\/a>. This charter formalises the\n                                commitments made by the Group to its European Works Council, with regard to\n                                iterative social dialogue and employee training in the safe, ethical and sustainable\n                                use of AI.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-32\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-44\">\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764686582_shutterstock_1082417942.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-22\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-40\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-25\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-36\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-32\">Telework : <\/strong><\/span>On 1 July, the\n                                banking group <span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-37\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-33\">BNP Paribas<\/strong><\/span> and\n                                its EWC revised their <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/european-charter-on-telework-in-the-bnp-paribas\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-43\">European\n                                    Charter on Teleworking<\/a>, replacing the <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/bnp-paribas-charter-on-telework-in-the-bnp-paribas-group\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-44\">text<\/a>\n                                adopted in November 2021. The new charter supplements the telework provisions of the\n                                November 2024 <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/bnp-paribas-agreement-on-the-fundamental-rights-and-global-social-floor-of-the-bnp-paribas-group\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-45\">Agreement\n                                    on the Fundamental Rights and Global Social Floor<\/a>, and contains a number of\n                                \u201ccommitments that were made specifically at the European level\u201d. It provides for\n                                specific monitoring of teleworking practice with the establishment of a monitoring\n                                commission, made up of the six members of the Bureau of the European Works Council,\n                                representatives of the European trade-union federations UNI Europe and FECEC, and\n                                management. The charter maintains the principle of \u201ca rate of work time exerted as\n                                teleworking at an individual maximum of 50%\u201d (with options for derogations) and\n                                regular presence on the site, in principle in \u201cthe form of a minimum of one day per\n                                week\u201d. The text also limits the length of any partial or total suspension of\n                                teleworking to six months, whether at management\u2019s or the employee\u2019s initiative, and\n                                at the end of this period, provides for an exchange between the manager and the\n                                employee on the organisation of the activity.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-33\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-45\">\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757508_shutterstock_2543899623.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-23\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-41\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-26\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-38\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-34\">Day of action : <\/strong><\/span>The EWC of the\n                                Spanish textile group <span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-39\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-35\">Inditex<\/strong>\n                                <\/span>has launched a day of action across Europe, with the support of the trade\n                                unions represented within the company, to demand a fairer distribution of the\n                                group\u2019s profits. Since it is impossible, in light of national legislations, to\n                                pursue simultaneous strike actions across the EU, the Spanish trade union CC.OO\n                                coordinated a series of demonstrations outside Zara stores in seven European\n                                countries on 28 November, which received good media coverage. \u201cAfter exhausting\n                                other avenues \u2013 a letter to the management, a petition at each meeting \u2013 the trade\n                                unions have decided on holding the rallies as a last resort\u201d, says the UNI Europa\n                                trade union federation (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.uni-europa.org\/news\/this-black-friday-zara-workers-across-europe-are-mobilising-for-higher-pay\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-46\">press\n                                    release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-34\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-46\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-42\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-22\">European\n                                company works council<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764757572_shutterstock_2533504667.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-24\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-43\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-27\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-40\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-36\">Combatting climate change : <\/strong><\/span>At\n                                the plenary meeting of the <span style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-41\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-37\">Clariane<\/strong>\n                                <\/span>group\u2019s European company Works Council, held on 20 November, the Works\n                                Council and management signed a <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/clariane-charter-of-the-european-society-works-council-and-clariane-management-to-accelerate-the-reduction-of-carbon-emissions\/\" class=\"irnotes-a-47\">charter\n                                    to accelerate the reduction of carbon emissions by the Clariane group<\/a>. This\n                                document is the outcome of work undertaken by a permanent CSR working group set up\n                                by the Works Council. The document makes recommendations to all actors within the\n                                company (management, employees and their representatives) structured around three\n                                themes: <span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-42\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-38\">1\/<\/strong><\/span> Inform, raise\n                                awareness and train employees; <span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-43\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-39\">2\/<\/strong><\/span>\n                                develop practices to reduce\n                                the company\u2019s carbon footprint; <span style=\"color: #000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-44\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-40\">3\/<\/strong><\/span>\n                                analyse the impacts of\n                                climate change and take action to protect employees and residents\/patients. For\n                                example, qualitative and quantitative carbon footprint indicators will be monitored\n                                by social dialogue bodies, especially the Works Council\u2019s CSR working group.\n                                Employee representatives undertake to support energy efficiency initiatives and\n                                green solutions, particularly when holding social dialogue meetings:\n                                videoconferencing, venues accessible by public transport, use of sustainable\n                                collective modes of transport, responsible local catering, reduction of plastic\n                                waste, etc. Employee representatives will also have to analyse the mapping of the\n                                exposure and vulnerability of establishments to climate risks at European and\n                                national level, and draw up associated action plans.<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n                <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-35\">\n                    <td class=\"irnotes-td-47\">\n                        <br \/>\n                        <font color=\"#7a1f10\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"3\" class=\"irnotes-font-44\"><b class=\"irnotes-b-23\">Trade\n                                unionism<\/b><\/font>\n                        <br \/><br \/><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/visuels\/1764687333_Image4.jpg\"\n                            style=\"max-width:150px; padding-right:10px\" align=\"left\" class=\"irnotes-img-25\" \/>\n                        <font color=\"#4c4d4d\" face=\"Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif\" size=\"-1\"\n                            style=\"text-align:justify\" class=\"irnotes-font-45\">\n                            <p class=\"irnotes-p-28\"><span style=\"color:#000000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-45\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-41\">Trade union network : <\/strong><\/span>On 17\n                                November, trade union representatives from Finland, France, Germany and Spain, and\n                                from the Finnish papermaking group <span\n                                    style=\"color: #800000;\" class=\"irnotes-span-46\"><strong class=\"irnotes-strong-42\">UPM<\/strong><\/span> met \u201cto align strategies,\n                                strengthen cross-border solidarity, and push back against UPM\u2019s deteriorating social\n                                dialogue\u201d, says IndustriAll Europe (see <a\n                                    href=\"https:\/\/www.industriall-europe.eu\/Article\/1386\" class=\"irnotes-a-48\">press release<\/a>).<\/p>\n                        <\/font>\n                    <\/td>\n                <\/tr>\n\n            <\/table>\n        <\/td>\n        <td width=\"10\" class=\"irnotes-td-48\">&nbsp;<\/td>\n    <\/tr>\n<\/table>\n<table width=\"660\" border=\"0\" cellspacing=\"0\" cellpadding=\"0\" align=\"center\" class=\"irnotes-table-9\">\n    <tr class=\"irnotes-tr-36\">\n        <td width=\"660\" valign=\"top\" align=\"center\" class=\"irnotes-td-49\">\n            <br><br>\n            <a href=\"{DESINSCRIPTION}\" class=\"irnotes-a-49\">D\u00e9sabonnement<\/a>\n        <\/td>\n    <\/tr>\n<\/table>\n<\/div>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>As indicated in our last edition (see IR Notes 262), Ireland\u2019s High Court has handed down an important judgment in the case brought by Jean-Philippe Charpentier, Verizon EWC Secretary (see IR Notes 250) against Verizon\u2019s management. The High Court overturned the decision pronounced on appeal by the Labour Court, which had found entirely in favour of the group\u2019s management.In November 2021, a number of EWC members acting in a personal capacity, including its secretary, took their case to the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC), which is the competent body for resolving collective labour disputes in Ireland [editor\u2019s note: under Irish law, an EWC has no legal personality of its own, and therefore cannot take matters to court]. The complainants applied for the company\u2019s management to be ordered to pay the costs they had incurred by taking part in a training course for EWC members, and also to pay certain expert legal costs incurred by the EWC. The WRC ruled that the EWC had already benefitted from a training day organised by management, so the latter was not obliged to reimburse the costs incurred by the 4 members in attending a further seminar \u2013 especially given that management had notified them in advance that they would not pay these costs. As for the expert costs, the WRC drew a distinction between areas of expertise that, in its view, qualified for reimbursement, and those that did not (see decision and IR Notes 207) and concluded that management should pay 50% of the eligible costs.\u00a0However, on appeal, on 27 August 2024, the Labour Court handed down two decisions: one confirming that the training costs did not have to be reimbursed, and the other dismissing the workforce representatives\u2019 application for expert costs to be refunded (see IR Notes 236). In fact the Labour Court overturned the WRC\u2019s decision, holding that the employees\u2019 representative was not entitled to act (decision TID241). As a last resort, the employee representatives then decided to refer the case to the High Court.In its judgment, which is the first one in this field handed down in Ireland, the High Court notes that the Labour Court had made several \u201cerrors of law\u201d. With the exception of training costs, which the High Court confirms did not have to be paid by the employer, given that it had already presented an EWC training course that was deemed adequate, the High Court disputes all of the Labour Court\u2019s conclusions. The Labour Court made errors of law by excluding a collective complaint filed by the EWC; by rejecting the EWC secretary\u2019s capacity as an EWC representative; by not ruling on the matter of whether the expert costs were necessary and appropriate;\u00a0and by not taking account of the application to have the legal fees of the EWC secretary\u2019s barrister refunded, solely on the grounds that its appeal had been rejected. In particular, the High Court notes that \u201cthe EWC, having no separate legal personality or independent financial resources, could only proceed with expert, including legal, advice and assistance\u201d. To ensure that EWC members\u2019 rights could be properly exercised, \u201cthe Labour Court should have considered whether it could, or should, permit an EWC or an employee to seek agreement from central management to reimburse all or some of the legal expenses associated with the claim on the basis that those expenses were necessary to satisfy the requirement of s. 17(1A) [editor\u2019s note: of the law transposing the European Works Council directive into Irish law] that an EWC member or employee representative had the means required to apply the rights conferred by the Directive.\u201dLooking beyond the Verizon case, this landmark case has made a significant contribution to the adoption of the revised European Works Council directive, which plans to abolish the legal restriction preventing an EWC from taking a matter to court, notably in Ireland, where any dispute must be instigated by individuals acting in a personal capacity, at their own expense \u2013 a situation that represents a practical obstacle to challenging any decisions made by management (see also\u00a0IR Notes 204).<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":11,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"_acf_changed":false,"footnotes":""},"categories":[1962],"tags":[],"post_country":[],"post_doc_language":[],"post_folder":[],"class_list":["post-33613","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-english-ir-notes-archive-newsletters"],"acf":[],"yoast_head":"<!-- This site is optimized with the Yoast SEO plugin v28.9 - https:\/\/yoast.com\/product\/yoast-seo-wordpress\/ -->\n<title>IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share<\/title>\n<meta name=\"robots\" content=\"index, follow, max-snippet:-1, max-image-preview:large, max-video-preview:-1\" \/>\n<link rel=\"canonical\" href=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:locale\" content=\"fr_FR\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:type\" content=\"article\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:title\" content=\"IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:description\" content=\"As indicated in our last edition (see IR Notes 262), Ireland\u2019s High Court has handed down an important judgment in the case brought by Jean-Philippe Charpentier, Verizon EWC Secretary (see IR Notes 250) against Verizon\u2019s management. The High Court overturned the decision pronounced on appeal by the Labour Court, which had found entirely in favour of the group\u2019s management.In November 2021, a number of EWC members acting in a personal capacity, including its secretary, took their case to the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC), which is the competent body for resolving collective labour disputes in Ireland [editor\u2019s note: under Irish law, an EWC has no legal personality of its own, and therefore cannot take matters to court]. The complainants applied for the company\u2019s management to be ordered to pay the costs they had incurred by taking part in a training course for EWC members, and also to pay certain expert legal costs incurred by the EWC. The WRC ruled that the EWC had already benefitted from a training day organised by management, so the latter was not obliged to reimburse the costs incurred by the 4 members in attending a further seminar \u2013 especially given that management had notified them in advance that they would not pay these costs. As for the expert costs, the WRC drew a distinction between areas of expertise that, in its view, qualified for reimbursement, and those that did not (see decision and IR Notes 207) and concluded that management should pay 50% of the eligible costs.\u00a0However, on appeal, on 27 August 2024, the Labour Court handed down two decisions: one confirming that the training costs did not have to be reimbursed, and the other dismissing the workforce representatives\u2019 application for expert costs to be refunded (see IR Notes 236). In fact the Labour Court overturned the WRC\u2019s decision, holding that the employees\u2019 representative was not entitled to act (decision TID241). As a last resort, the employee representatives then decided to refer the case to the High Court.In its judgment, which is the first one in this field handed down in Ireland, the High Court notes that the Labour Court had made several \u201cerrors of law\u201d. With the exception of training costs, which the High Court confirms did not have to be paid by the employer, given that it had already presented an EWC training course that was deemed adequate, the High Court disputes all of the Labour Court\u2019s conclusions. The Labour Court made errors of law by excluding a collective complaint filed by the EWC; by rejecting the EWC secretary\u2019s capacity as an EWC representative; by not ruling on the matter of whether the expert costs were necessary and appropriate;\u00a0and by not taking account of the application to have the legal fees of the EWC secretary\u2019s barrister refunded, solely on the grounds that its appeal had been rejected. In particular, the High Court notes that \u201cthe EWC, having no separate legal personality or independent financial resources, could only proceed with expert, including legal, advice and assistance\u201d. To ensure that EWC members\u2019 rights could be properly exercised, \u201cthe Labour Court should have considered whether it could, or should, permit an EWC or an employee to seek agreement from central management to reimburse all or some of the legal expenses associated with the claim on the basis that those expenses were necessary to satisfy the requirement of s. 17(1A) [editor\u2019s note: of the law transposing the European Works Council directive into Irish law] that an EWC member or employee representative had the means required to apply the rights conferred by the Directive.\u201dLooking beyond the Verizon case, this landmark case has made a significant contribution to the adoption of the revised European Works Council directive, which plans to abolish the legal restriction preventing an EWC from taking a matter to court, notably in Ireland, where any dispute must be instigated by individuals acting in a personal capacity, at their own expense \u2013 a situation that represents a practical obstacle to challenging any decisions made by management (see also\u00a0IR Notes 204).\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:url\" content=\"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:site_name\" content=\"IR Share\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:published_time\" content=\"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"article:modified_time\" content=\"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00\" \/>\n<meta property=\"og:image\" content=\"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif\" \/>\n<meta name=\"author\" content=\"Konstantin\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:card\" content=\"summary_large_image\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:creator\" content=\"@IR_Share\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:site\" content=\"@IR_Share\" \/>\n<meta name=\"twitter:label1\" content=\"\u00c9crit par\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data1\" content=\"Konstantin\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:label2\" content=\"Dur\u00e9e de lecture estim\u00e9e\" \/>\n\t<meta name=\"twitter:data2\" content=\"16 minutes\" \/>\n<script type=\"application\/ld+json\" class=\"yoast-schema-graph\">{\"@context\":\"https:\\\/\\\/schema.org\",\"@graph\":[{\"@type\":\"Article\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#article\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/\"},\"author\":{\"name\":\"Konstantin\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/c47c3eece71666bf9a1a1cee539d04dd\"},\"headline\":\"IR Notes 263 &#8211; Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC\",\"datePublished\":\"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00\",\"mainEntityOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/\"},\"wordCount\":3199,\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#organization\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#primaryimage\"},\"thumbnailUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/archive.irshare.eu\\\/irnotes\\\/logo-entete.gif\",\"articleSection\":[\"English IR Notes Archive Newsletters\"],\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\"},{\"@type\":\"WebPage\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/\",\"name\":\"IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share\",\"isPartOf\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#website\"},\"primaryImageOfPage\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#primaryimage\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#primaryimage\"},\"thumbnailUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/archive.irshare.eu\\\/irnotes\\\/logo-entete.gif\",\"datePublished\":\"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00\",\"dateModified\":\"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00\",\"breadcrumb\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#breadcrumb\"},\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\",\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"ReadAction\",\"target\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/\"]}]},{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#primaryimage\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/archive.irshare.eu\\\/irnotes\\\/logo-entete.gif\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/archive.irshare.eu\\\/irnotes\\\/logo-entete.gif\"},{\"@type\":\"BreadcrumbList\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\\\/#breadcrumb\",\"itemListElement\":[{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":1,\"name\":\"Home\",\"item\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/\"},{\"@type\":\"ListItem\",\"position\":2,\"name\":\"IR Notes 263 &#8211; Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC\"}]},{\"@type\":\"WebSite\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#website\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/\",\"name\":\"IR Share\",\"description\":\"A Resource Hub for Labour Law and Industrial Relations\",\"publisher\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#organization\"},\"potentialAction\":[{\"@type\":\"SearchAction\",\"target\":{\"@type\":\"EntryPoint\",\"urlTemplate\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/?s={search_term_string}\"},\"query-input\":{\"@type\":\"PropertyValueSpecification\",\"valueRequired\":true,\"valueName\":\"search_term_string\"}}],\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\"},{\"@type\":\"Organization\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#organization\",\"name\":\"IR Share\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/\",\"logo\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/2024\\\/06\\\/irsharelogo.png\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/wp-content\\\/uploads\\\/2024\\\/06\\\/irsharelogo.png\",\"width\":315,\"height\":100,\"caption\":\"IR Share\"},\"image\":{\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/logo\\\/image\\\/\"},\"sameAs\":[\"https:\\\/\\\/x.com\\\/IR_Share\"]},{\"@type\":\"Person\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/divi5.irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/#\\\/schema\\\/person\\\/c47c3eece71666bf9a1a1cee539d04dd\",\"name\":\"Konstantin\",\"image\":{\"@type\":\"ImageObject\",\"inLanguage\":\"fr-FR\",\"@id\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"contentUrl\":\"https:\\\/\\\/secure.gravatar.com\\\/avatar\\\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g\",\"caption\":\"Konstantin\"},\"url\":\"https:\\\/\\\/irshare.eu\\\/fr\\\/author\\\/konstantin\\\/\"}]}<\/script>\n<!-- \/ Yoast SEO plugin. -->","yoast_head_json":{"title":"IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share","robots":{"index":"index","follow":"follow","max-snippet":"max-snippet:-1","max-image-preview":"max-image-preview:large","max-video-preview":"max-video-preview:-1"},"canonical":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/","og_locale":"fr_FR","og_type":"article","og_title":"IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share","og_description":"As indicated in our last edition (see IR Notes 262), Ireland\u2019s High Court has handed down an important judgment in the case brought by Jean-Philippe Charpentier, Verizon EWC Secretary (see IR Notes 250) against Verizon\u2019s management. The High Court overturned the decision pronounced on appeal by the Labour Court, which had found entirely in favour of the group\u2019s management.In November 2021, a number of EWC members acting in a personal capacity, including its secretary, took their case to the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC), which is the competent body for resolving collective labour disputes in Ireland [editor\u2019s note: under Irish law, an EWC has no legal personality of its own, and therefore cannot take matters to court]. The complainants applied for the company\u2019s management to be ordered to pay the costs they had incurred by taking part in a training course for EWC members, and also to pay certain expert legal costs incurred by the EWC. The WRC ruled that the EWC had already benefitted from a training day organised by management, so the latter was not obliged to reimburse the costs incurred by the 4 members in attending a further seminar \u2013 especially given that management had notified them in advance that they would not pay these costs. As for the expert costs, the WRC drew a distinction between areas of expertise that, in its view, qualified for reimbursement, and those that did not (see decision and IR Notes 207) and concluded that management should pay 50% of the eligible costs.\u00a0However, on appeal, on 27 August 2024, the Labour Court handed down two decisions: one confirming that the training costs did not have to be reimbursed, and the other dismissing the workforce representatives\u2019 application for expert costs to be refunded (see IR Notes 236). In fact the Labour Court overturned the WRC\u2019s decision, holding that the employees\u2019 representative was not entitled to act (decision TID241). As a last resort, the employee representatives then decided to refer the case to the High Court.In its judgment, which is the first one in this field handed down in Ireland, the High Court notes that the Labour Court had made several \u201cerrors of law\u201d. With the exception of training costs, which the High Court confirms did not have to be paid by the employer, given that it had already presented an EWC training course that was deemed adequate, the High Court disputes all of the Labour Court\u2019s conclusions. The Labour Court made errors of law by excluding a collective complaint filed by the EWC; by rejecting the EWC secretary\u2019s capacity as an EWC representative; by not ruling on the matter of whether the expert costs were necessary and appropriate;\u00a0and by not taking account of the application to have the legal fees of the EWC secretary\u2019s barrister refunded, solely on the grounds that its appeal had been rejected. In particular, the High Court notes that \u201cthe EWC, having no separate legal personality or independent financial resources, could only proceed with expert, including legal, advice and assistance\u201d. To ensure that EWC members\u2019 rights could be properly exercised, \u201cthe Labour Court should have considered whether it could, or should, permit an EWC or an employee to seek agreement from central management to reimburse all or some of the legal expenses associated with the claim on the basis that those expenses were necessary to satisfy the requirement of s. 17(1A) [editor\u2019s note: of the law transposing the European Works Council directive into Irish law] that an EWC member or employee representative had the means required to apply the rights conferred by the Directive.\u201dLooking beyond the Verizon case, this landmark case has made a significant contribution to the adoption of the revised European Works Council directive, which plans to abolish the legal restriction preventing an EWC from taking a matter to court, notably in Ireland, where any dispute must be instigated by individuals acting in a personal capacity, at their own expense \u2013 a situation that represents a practical obstacle to challenging any decisions made by management (see also\u00a0IR Notes 204).","og_url":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/","og_site_name":"IR Share","article_published_time":"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00","article_modified_time":"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00","og_image":[{"url":"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif","type":"","width":"","height":""}],"author":"Konstantin","twitter_card":"summary_large_image","twitter_creator":"@IR_Share","twitter_site":"@IR_Share","twitter_misc":{"\u00c9crit par":"Konstantin","Dur\u00e9e de lecture estim\u00e9e":"16 minutes"},"schema":{"@context":"https:\/\/schema.org","@graph":[{"@type":"Article","@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#article","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/"},"author":{"name":"Konstantin","@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#\/schema\/person\/c47c3eece71666bf9a1a1cee539d04dd"},"headline":"IR Notes 263 &#8211; Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC","datePublished":"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00","dateModified":"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00","mainEntityOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/"},"wordCount":3199,"publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#organization"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#primaryimage"},"thumbnailUrl":"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif","articleSection":["English IR Notes Archive Newsletters"],"inLanguage":"fr-FR"},{"@type":"WebPage","@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/","url":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/","name":"IR Notes 263 - Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC - IR Share","isPartOf":{"@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#website"},"primaryImageOfPage":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#primaryimage"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#primaryimage"},"thumbnailUrl":"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif","datePublished":"2025-12-03T12:00:00+00:00","dateModified":"2026-07-02T17:46:02+00:00","breadcrumb":{"@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#breadcrumb"},"inLanguage":"fr-FR","potentialAction":[{"@type":"ReadAction","target":["https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/"]}]},{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"fr-FR","@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#primaryimage","url":"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif","contentUrl":"https:\/\/archive.irshare.eu\/irnotes\/logo-entete.gif"},{"@type":"BreadcrumbList","@id":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/ir-notes-263-03-december-2025\/#breadcrumb","itemListElement":[{"@type":"ListItem","position":1,"name":"Home","item":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/"},{"@type":"ListItem","position":2,"name":"IR Notes 263 &#8211; Towards an epilogue in the landmark case of Verizon\u2019s EWC"}]},{"@type":"WebSite","@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#website","url":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/","name":"IR Share","description":"A Resource Hub for Labour Law and Industrial Relations","publisher":{"@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#organization"},"potentialAction":[{"@type":"SearchAction","target":{"@type":"EntryPoint","urlTemplate":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/?s={search_term_string}"},"query-input":{"@type":"PropertyValueSpecification","valueRequired":true,"valueName":"search_term_string"}}],"inLanguage":"fr-FR"},{"@type":"Organization","@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#organization","name":"IR Share","url":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/","logo":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"fr-FR","@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/","url":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/irsharelogo.png","contentUrl":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/wp-content\/uploads\/2024\/06\/irsharelogo.png","width":315,"height":100,"caption":"IR Share"},"image":{"@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#\/schema\/logo\/image\/"},"sameAs":["https:\/\/x.com\/IR_Share"]},{"@type":"Person","@id":"https:\/\/divi5.irshare.eu\/fr\/#\/schema\/person\/c47c3eece71666bf9a1a1cee539d04dd","name":"Konstantin","image":{"@type":"ImageObject","inLanguage":"fr-FR","@id":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g","url":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g","contentUrl":"https:\/\/secure.gravatar.com\/avatar\/5fdc2851c8df81301d78d063f9f34dbdde9b7f0dab479fd6be667f5ec8e4cbf0?s=96&d=mm&r=g","caption":"Konstantin"},"url":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/author\/konstantin\/"}]}},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/33613","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/11"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=33613"}],"version-history":[{"count":2,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/33613\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":35469,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/33613\/revisions\/35469"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=33613"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=33613"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=33613"},{"taxonomy":"post_country","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/post_country?post=33613"},{"taxonomy":"post_doc_language","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/post_doc_language?post=33613"},{"taxonomy":"post_folder","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/irshare.eu\/fr\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/post_folder?post=33613"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}