IR Notes 284 – Reason prevails as an unreasonable dispute draws to a close

  • November 19, 2026

Reason prevails as an unreasonable dispute draws to a close

Lead story

Reason prevails as an unreasonable dispute draws to a close

Reason prevails as an unreasonable dispute draws to a close

The obstinacy displayed by Verizon’s management in refusing to pay expert assistance (11,220 euros) and training (750 euros) costs incurred by its European Works Council has culminated in a judgment issued by the Irish Supreme Court on 10 November. The judgment will affect the many multinational companies that, in the wake of Brexit, chose to place their EWC under the rule of Irish law.

The dispute that the Supreme Court was ruling on concerned an invoice issued by the consultancy firm EWC Academy, for advice provided in early 2021. The application for reimbursement training costs was no longer being pursued: the Irish Labour Court, whose judgment was confirmed by the High Court, had previously found in Verizon’s favour on this point. Verizon had no issue with the EWC’s choice of expert or with his rates. It was merely disputing some of the services he had provided: reviewing the minutes, the advice regarding UK delegates, work on a project that did not proceed and details of the procedural rules. The EWC secretary was also seeking reimbursement of the legal costs incurred in asserting the EWC’s rights (see IR Notes 263).

The Supreme Court’s interpretation of the means granted to the EWC by Directive 2009/38, and especially by the subsidiary requirements governing Verizon’s EWC, is very clear. It dismisses Verizon’s interpretation, namely that these means are limited to the capacity to bring action before the courts. The Court relies on the wording, the context and the purpose of the directive. The extent of this obligation is defined by points 5 and 6 of the subsidiary requirements: the assistance of experts “insofar as this is necessary for it to carry out its tasks” and payment of operating expenses. The Court states that “those tasks must include relying upon the rights arising from the Directive of 2009 to represent collectively the interests of the employees”. Therefore, “retaining a lawyer for that purpose potentially constitutes assistance from an expert to apply the rights under the Directive”. Contrary to Verizon’s submission, Directive 2025/2450 does not introduce these obligations: the Court’s view is that the directive makes them explicit and conditions them. In other words, they already exist in Directive 2009/38. The Court considers the whole situation to be so clear that it refuses to refer the case to the EU Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling. This is what this ruling tells us in terms of principles. However, there is one qualification: the Court’s reasoning here applies to EWCs governed by subsidiary requirements. The extent of the means required by EWCs established by means of an agreement, on the other hand, will depend on what is provided in that agreement.

Nevertheless, this does not involve providing a “blank cheque”. The Court clearly states that management’s obligations only extend to paying necessary expenses that are reasonably incurred. It will be the Labour Court’s duty to check whether each of the disputed services was “necessary”. It will have to take account of the fact that the EWC engaged the expert without warning management and without informing it of the scope of his mission, which had already led the Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) to halve the amount that could be claimed back. As for legal expenses, the Supreme Court holds that in principle, these form part of the EWC’s operating expenses. The EWC secretary must therefore submit an itemised application to management and, if this is rejected, it must refer the matter to the WRC, and subsequently to the Labour Court on appeal, if applicable. The court to which the case is referred will then have to check, among other things, whether it was necessary to use a lawyer, and to take into account whether authorisation was requested in advance.

Tom Hayes, a senior consultant at BEERG, who advises numerous multinational companies, warns: “the Supreme Court comes very close to saying that expenses incurred by an EWC should be approved in advance by management. If an EWC goes ahead and incurs expenses without prior approval then it is unlikely to be successful at the Workplace Relations Commission/Labour Court if these expenses are disputed. If there is no guarantee of payment, lawyers and experts will be reluctant to work for EWCs.” Verizon EWC secretary Jean-Philippe Charpentier is pleased with the outcome: “this is an excellent judgment from our point of view, but the case is still ongoing, because we must now look to management to reimburse the monies owed.”

It is to be hoped that the Irish transposition of Directive 2025/2450 will genuinely facilitate access to justice for EWCs and in the future, will eliminate questionable conduct such as this, which has led Verizon to spend an amount probably 100 times greater than the sums disputed.

European social update

Social update

Social update

A 2027 work programme light on social content: On 4 November, the European Commission unveiled its work programme for 2027, in which it promises to “safeguard our unique social market economic model, where people always come first”. It plans to deliver on this commitment by organising a summit to reaffirm the EU’s attachment to the European Pillar of Social Rights, which will mark its tenth anniversary in 2027. In the social arena, it is putting forward a number of non-binding initiatives, such as a European Care Deal; a Skills Guarantee to encourage workers to move into growth sectors; and a strategy on the “right to stay”, in light of the demographic decline seen by some regions. The programme also includes a housing simplification package (aimed at making housing affordable) and thinking on how young people can be provided with support in response to AI’s impact on the labour market. It reaffirms its proposed “pact against gold-plating” (see IR Notes 282), which the European Trade Union Confederation is threatening to challenge in court unless social directives are excluded from this legislation (see press release). Eurocadres is dismissive of a programme that is “devoid of ambition or hope” (see press release). The scant social content in the Commission’s work programme can be explained in large measure by the publication of the Quality Jobs Act, the date of which has been announced for 2 December. Among other things, this is expected to cover telework, the right to disconnect, psychosocial risks, algorithmic management and subcontracting. It is in this Act that the Commission’s social ambitions will be played out.

A Vocational Education and Training strategy: On 5 November, the European Commission unveiled a European Vocational Education and Training (VET) strategy (see press release and factsheet), as part of an Education and Skills package (see press release). This initiative has been taken because the EU is lagging behind in the area of adult learning: the target is for 60% of adults to undergo training every year between now and 2030, whereas Eurostat recorded this figure at just 39.5% in 2022. Among other things, this strategy establishes a European sectoral training accelerator pilot project, with a view to offering short and flexible training modules, developed in collaboration with industry. The strategy was welcomed by European social partners in the metalworking industry (IndustriAll Europe and Ceemet) in a joint statement issued on 12 November (see press release), and by BusinessEurope (see press release).

Case law

ECtHR finds Switzerland retrospectively guilty of unlawful conduct: In a chamber judgment pronounced on 5 November, the European Court of Human Rights reached a unanimous verdict that Switzerland had committed a two-fold breach of Article 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights (freedom of assembly and association). The case began in 2012, when the La Providence private hospital withdrew from the CCT collective bargaining agreement applicable to the health sector, at a time when the GSMN group was preparing to take over the hospital. A strike supported by two trade unions began in November 2012. On 23 January 2013, management announced the undertakings given by the company effecting the takeover: the CCT agreement would remain in place until the end of 2013 and all hospital staff would be guaranteed employment. Management issued a formal warning to the strikers to return to work. On 4 February, 22 employees who were still on strike were dismissed with immediate effect. For their part, the trade union secretaries received criminal convictions for trespassing, as a result of the picket line set up in front of the hospital. The Federal Court had ruled that the strike, which was lawful at the outset, could no longer be considered a measure of last resort [ultima ratio] after 23 January. In the view of the ECtHR, neither Article 28 of the Swiss Constitution nor case law provided a clear basis for concluding that a lawful strike could become unlawful because a court, with the benefit of hindsight, considered that an employer’s offer had made the continuation of the strike unnecessary. Such uncertainty renders the right to strike devoid of substance. In the first instance, it is up to the trade unions to judge whether industrial action should be continued, while the courts retain control of the principle of proportionality. With regard to the criminal convictions, the Court points out that peaceful picketing is legally protected. It also emphasises the “deterrent effect” of these sanctions on trade-union action. The judgment is not final: it can still be referred to the Court’s Grand Chamber (see press release).

Across Europe

Across Europe

Luxembourg

Reform of working time arrangements: On 13 November, the Permanent Labour and Employment Committee (CPTE), which is a tripartite body, approved the principle of a four-day week. This go-ahead will enable the Minister of Labour to submit a draft law to the Chamber of Deputies for a vote that the government wishes to hold in early 2027 (see Ministry of Labour press release). This move is not about reducing working time but compressing the current 40-hour working week into four days. The new legislation should also provide for the possibility of taking two unpaid breaks per day instead of one; a reduction in the 44-hour weekly rest period, without going below the threshold of 35 hours; an exceptional extension of working time in the event of an emergency; and a variation, from one week to the next, of up to 50% in the weekly working hours of part-time employees (compared to the current figure of 20%). These flexible arrangements will have to be negotiated and governed by a collective agreement, though the employers’ organisation UEL, which was calling for exceptions to be granted to companies with fewer than 50 employees, is unhappy about this requirement (see press release). This was a red line for the trade unions, which rejected the idea of any changes being made to working hours without a collective bargaining process (see OGBL press release).

  France

Transposing the Platform Work directive: A report submitted to the Minister of Labour on 2 November makes 30 recommendations for transposing Directive 2024/2831 on Platform Work into French law. The fact-finding mission rules out any automatic presumption of employed status and proposes bringing the burden of proof into line with the anti-discrimination law model: a worker would submit evidence implying a link of subordination, and it would then be incumbent on the platform to prove otherwise. This mechanism would go hand in hand with fast-track court proceedings. Its key recommendation is attaching mobility platform workers, who are mainly delivery workers, to the Accidents at Work branch of the general social security scheme and having their contributions paid by platforms. The cost of delivering this measure is estimated at 27 million euros per year. The mission also advocates a minimum pay level, negotiated either by social partners or fixed by decree, in the absence of any agreement. For algorithmic transparency purposes, it proposes having two levels of information: firstly, detailed technical information to be used solely by the authorities and workers’ representatives, and secondly, a summary of personal details, to be given to each worker. The government is due to submit the outlines of a draft law to social partners by 2 December, which is the deadline for transposition.

  Italy

Working via digital platforms: On 28 October, the Council of Ministers definitively adopted the legislative decree transposing Directive 2024/2831 on Platform Work. This text covers all platforms that organise work performed in Italy, except those whose activity is limited to bringing together supply and demand. It creates a simple presumption of employed status where the platform exercises powers of direction and control, including by means of an algorithm: it is then up to the platform to prove that the worker is genuinely self-employed. Moreover, it will no longer be possible for any suspension or closure of an account, or any termination of an employment relationship, to be based solely on an automated system. The text also assigns a key role to collective bargaining, especially for the purpose of fixing pay and applying algorithmic management-related rights. The presumption of employed status will apply from 2 December onwards.

United Kingdom

Towards Responsible Business Conduct: On 4 November, in a ministerial written statement to Parliament on responsible business conduct (RBC), the government committed to passing due diligence legislation in the field of human rights. This legislation will apply to UK businesses with a global turnover of over £350 million (approx. €420 million), as well as non-UK businesses with a UK-generated turnover exceeding the same threshold. Environmental issues do not appear to be covered. A regulator will be empowered to investigate goods made with forced labour and direct their withdrawal from the Great Britain market (see press release).

  Germany

Codetermination model called into question: Codetermination, an arrangement that lies at the heart of Germany’s industrial relations model, is the subject of a critical report issued by the employers’ organisation BDA, which is calling for the law on company formation to be modernised. The report urges that employers should be allowed to have faster decision-making processes, a move that would restrict or even abolish codecision-making rights. At the present time, where there is disagreement, these rights require the employer and employee representatives to refer the matter to a conciliation committee, thereby delaying the decision still further. Among other things, the report takes aim at codecision-making with regard to the introduction and use of technical equipment designed to monitor employees’ behaviour and performance. IG Metall is firmly opposed to these recommendations (see press release).

  Germany

A plan enabling the chemical industry to weather the crisis: Social partners in the chemical sector have submitted a twelve-point plan to the government. Its aim is to boost the competitiveness and resilience of Germany’s chemical industry, protect jobs and guarantee good working conditions. This plan has been drawn up in response to the invitation sent by the federal government to social partners in sectors particularly severely affected by the crisis.

Company updates

Company updates

Suez EWC visits the Czech Republic: Members of the Suez EWC went on a mission to the Czech Republic from 19 to 22 October, to meet local staff teams and find out more about the group’s water-related activities (they toured a drinking water treatment plant and two wastewater treatment plants, and were given a presentation on a public-private partnership model). They held discussions with local management and employee representatives. EWC secretary Christine Chiffre explains: “These on-site missions are vital for enhancing our appreciation of the diversity of the group’s activities in Europe, understanding local realities and sharing experience among different countries”.

Data and reports

Data and reports

AI literacy, the new basic skill for Europe’s workforce

AI literacy, the new basic skill for Europe’s workforce

An inter-agency report on vocational education and training (VET) examines how AI is changing the skills required in the workplace (see press release). This working group – made up of researchers from six European and international organisations, including Cedefop, Eurofound and the ILO –, claims that AI is transforming the task content of jobs more than it is affecting their number. It is increasing the demand for advanced cognitive, digital and socio-emotional skills. The authors argue that AI literacy, which is simultaneously technical, analytical and ethical in nature, is now a basic skill requiring lifelong development. According to a Cedefop survey conducted in 2024 in eleven EU Member States, 28% of adult workers are already using AI at their workplace. Since the introduction of AI, around one third of workers no longer do some tasks, four in ten are now doing new tasks, and two in three are doing some tasks faster. Lastly, AI-specialised jobs still account for only a small share of overall employment (between 0.3% and 5%, depending on the definition). However, they are gaining ground rapidly, and according to Lightcast data cited by the report, more than one half of AI-related job offers now concern occupations outside the field of IT.

Download the report

Key Statistic

16 to 17%

of workers are now having their performance monitored or assessed by algorithms, according to the abovementioned report. Around one in seven workers say these tools determine how some tasks are carried out. The authors emphasise the risks linked to data protection and work intensification, and call for ethical and organisational safeguards.

Other IR Notes

We are called upon to devise training programmes based on needs expressed by a number of companies; we publish analyses and create tailor-made training activities for groups, works councils, trade unions and law firms. Our most recent projects are described here

IR Notes 283 – Governments appear less than enthusiastic about the Quality Jobs Act

On 19 October, addressing EU Ministers of Employment, Roxana Mînzatu, Executive Vice-President of […]

IR Notes 282 – The Commission is ready to bring out a new law that may undermine social rights

In Brussels, the need to boost competitiveness continues to fire the imagination of […]

IR Notes 281 – Two irreconcilable visions for the future Quality Jobs Act

On 28 September, the European social partners submitted their responses to the European […]

IR Notes 280 – Social criteria to play a more important role in the rules governing public procurement contracts

On 22 July, the European Commission published a communication reviewing the progress made […]